Browsing by Author "Swarthout, Avery"

Now showing 1 - 6 of 6
  • Thumbnail Image
    ItemUnknown
    A comparative assessment of multi-objective optimisation methodologies for aero-engine nacelles
    (ICAS, 2022-09-09) Swarthout, Avery; MacManus, David; Tejero, Fernando; Matesanz García, Jesús; Boscagli, Luca; Sheaf, Christopher
    There are significant environmental and economic drivers for the development of more fuel-efficient commercial aircraft engines. The propulsive efficiency benefits of ultra-high bypass ratio turbofans may be counteracted by the drag and weight penalty associated with larger nacelles. A more compact nacelle design may therefore be necessary to reduce these penalties. However, increasing compactness also increases the sensitivity of the nacelle to boundary layer separation under off-design windmilling conditions. This paper investigates methods for incorporating windmilling considerations alongside design point requirements within a multi-objective, multi-point optimisation. Windmilling under aircraft diversion and at the end-of-runway (EoR) condition are considered. The windmilling conditions are assessed through a combination of regression and classification type criteria. The transonic aerodynamics of the nacelle at the design point are notably different from the transonic characteristics at the diversion windmilling conditions. Meanwhile, the aerodynamics, and separation mechanisms, at the end-of-runway condition are dominated by subsonic diffusion. Overall, a combination of regression and classification mechanisms are found to be most suitable for the nacelle optimization as it delivers a design population which is favorably balanced between robustness against boundary layer separation as well as delivering nacelle drag benefits.
  • Thumbnail Image
    ItemUnknown
    Design of a new test rig to investigate transonic external fan cowl separation
    (Association Aeronautique Astronautique de France, 2022-03-28) Sabnis, Kshitij; Boscagli, Luca; Swarthout, Avery; Babinsky, Holger; MacManus, David; Sheaf, Christopher T.
    Ultra high-bypass ratio engines, which show considerable promise in reducing the environmental impact of commercial aviation, generally adopt slim fan cowl profiles. These geometries can be more sensitive to separation on the external surfaces in engine windmilling conditions during take-off climb out or during cruise. This paper describes the development of a two-dimensional wind tunnel rig which can accurately replicate the separation mechanisms experienced by real aero-engine nacelles. This design process highlights the importance of considering factors such as Reynolds-number effects, tunnel-wall effects, the two-dimensional nature of the rig, and the tunnel boundary layers.
  • Thumbnail Image
    ItemUnknown
    Design of a quasi-2D rig configuration to assess nacelle aerodynamics under windmilling conditions
    (AIAA, 2023-06-08) Boscagli, Luca; Tejero, Fernando; Swarthout, Avery; MacManus, David G.; Sabnis, Kshitij; Babinsky, Holger; Sheaf, Christopher
    Aero-engine nacelles are typically designed to fulfil both design and off-design aircraft manoeuvres. Under-off design conditions one of the objective is to avoid large flow separation either on the external cowl or within the intake that can influence aircraft and engine operability. One particular scenario is represented by a low engine mass flow regime associated with one inoperative engine, also known as a windmilling condition. Under windmilling, the boundary layer on the external cowl of the nacelle can separate either due to the interaction with shockwaves or due to notable adverse pressure gradient towards the trailing edge. Both mechanisms are computationally difficult to model and there is a need for more validation of computational fluid dynamics (CFD) methods. The aim of this work is to develop a rig configuration which will provide CFD validation data for the aerodynamics of a nacelle under representative windmilling conditions. Two flight regimes are considered, namely windmilling diversion and end-of-runway. CFD simulations of a 3D nacelle are used to determine primary aerodynamic mechanisms associated with boundary layer separation. Two rig configurations are developed and both 2D and 3D CFD analyses are used to achieve the design objectives. Overall, this work presents the design philosophy and methods that were pursued to develop a quasi-2D rig configuration representative of the aerodynamics of 3D-annular aero-engine nacelles under windmilling conditions.
  • Thumbnail Image
    ItemUnknown
    Towards the design and optimisation of future compact aero-engines: intake/fancowl trade-off investigation
    (Emerald, 2022-12-09) Tejero, Fernando; MacManus, David; Matesanz García, Jesús; Swarthout, Avery; Sheaf, Christopher
    Purpose Relative to in-service aero-engines, the bypass ratio of future civil architectures may increase further. If traditional design rules are applied to these new configurations and the housing components are scaled, then it is expected that the overall weight, nacelle drag and the effects of aircraft integration will increase. For this reason, the next generation of civil turbofan engines may use compact nacelles to maximise the benefits from the new engine cycles. The purpose of this paper is to present a multi-level design and optimisation process for future civil aero-engines. Design/methodology/approach An initial set of multi-point, multi-objective optimisations for axisymmetric configurations are carried out to identify the trade-off between intake and fancowl bulk parameters of highlight radius and nacelle length on nacelle drag. Having identified the likely optimal part of the design space, a set of computationally expensive optimisations for three-dimensional non-axisymmetric configurations is performed. The process includes cruise- and windmilling-type operating conditions to ensure aerodynamic robustness of the downselected configurations. Findings Relative to a conventional aero-engine nacelle, the developed process yielded a compact aero-engine configuration with mid-cruise drag reduction of approximately 1.6% of the nominal standard net thrust. Originality/value The multi-point, multi-objective optimisation is carried out with a mixture of regression and classification functions to ensure aerodynamic robustness of the downselected configurations. The developed computational approach enables the optimisation of future civil aero-engine nacelles that target a reduction of the overall fuel consumption.
  • Thumbnail Image
    ItemUnknown
    Towards the design and optimisation of future compact aero-engines: intake/fancowl trade-off investigation
    (Unconfirmed, 2022-03-30) Tejero, Fernando; MacManus, David G.; Matesanz García, Jesús; Swarthout, Avery; Sheaf, Christopher
    Relative to in-service aero-engines, the bypass ratio of future civil architectures may increase further. If traditional design rules are applied to these new configurations and the housing components are scaled then it is expected that the overall weight, nacelle drag and the effects of aircraft integration will increase. For this reason, the next generation of civil turbofan engines may use compact nacelles to maximise the benefits from the new engine cycles. This paper presents a multi-level design and optimisation process for future civil aero-engines. An initial set of multi-point, multi-objective optimisations for axisymmetric configurations are carried out to identify the trade-off between intake and fancowl bulk parameters of highlight radius and nacelle length on nacelle drag. Having identified the likely optimal part of the design space, a set of computationally expensive optimisations for 3D non-axisymmetric configurations are performed. The process includes cruise- and windmilling-type operating conditions to ensure aerodynamic robustness of the downselected configurations. Relative to a conventional aero-engine nacelle, the developed process yielded a compact aero-engine configuration with mid-cruise drag reduction of approximately 1.6% of the nominal standard net thrust.
  • Thumbnail Image
    ItemUnknown
    A wind tunnel rig to study the external fan cowl separation experienced by compact nacelles in windmilling scenarios
    (AIAA, 2023-01-19) Sabnis, Kshitij; Babinsky, Holger; Boscagli, Luca; Swarthout, Avery; Tejero, Fernando; MacManus, David; Sheaf, Christopher
    Ultra high-bypass ratio aircraft engines adopt slim fan cowl profiles which are sensitive to separation on their external surfaces under diversion windmilling conditions, when engine shutdown occurs during cruise. A two-dimensional wind tunnel rig is developed to investigate the separation mechanisms experienced by aero-engine nacelles in such scenarios to establish the detailed aerodynamics. The tunnel flow field with entry Mach number 0.65 broadly replicates the expected diversion windmilling flow behaviour for a full-scale nacelle, featuring a supersonic region which terminates in a normal shock wave on the external fan cowl surface. For the three conditions investigated, which relate to different engine mass-flow rates, the response of the boundary layer in this region progresses from remaining fully attached through to well-established separation. However, the rig Reynolds number based on nacelle lip thickness is about 1.2 million, roughly one-third of full scale, resulting in a transitional rather than turbulent shock-boundary-layer interaction. Nevertheless, simple simulations correctly predict the wind tunnel flow field, except for the precise boundary-layer response to normal shock waves, and so experimental data from the rig can be used to validate relevant computational methods.